Join our email list here:


Bad Neighbors Require Good Fences

Carl Pearlston- Monday 1st Sep 2003

The fence snakes its way for miles over dry hills and valleys, imposing and forbidding in its 12-15-ft height. In some areas, there are two rows of this wall, separated by a patrol road, and at night there are brilliant lights to supplement the motion detectors and television cameras which monitor attempts to cross by those on the other side.

The construction of the fence has been widely and uniformly condemned by human rights groups, other governments, environmentalists, and religious organizations, who point out the hardship this wall inflicts on the excluded population. Undaunted by the criticism, the government plans to add another 260 miles to the existing 70 miles of such fencing, to more effectively seal its border, making it 2 ¨` times the length of the former Berlin Wall.

No, this fence is not the one in Israel; they are constructing a similar barrier to this which the U.S. has on its Mexican border. The big difference is that the Israeli fence is designed to keep out people who want to kill them, while the U.S. fence keeps out people who are illegally looking for jobs and a chance to better their lives. israel wall

If the U.S. is justified by reasons of national security in building this wall against the population of a country with whom we are at peace, how can the U.S. reasonably criticize Israel for doing the same against a population intent on its destruction? President Bush, who opposes the Israeli fence, said at a recent press conference that if the Palestinian terrorist organizations were dismantled, then "a fence would be irrelevant." But we have a formidable security barrier at our Mexican border, even though there are no Mexican terrorist organizations intent on exploding bombs on buses in San Diego and Los Angeles.

We want to control our borders, even in time of peace; Israel should be given every opportunity to do the same, especially in time of war. The history of the past 55 years does not inspire optimism for the dismantlement of Palestinian terrorist organizations.

The arguments against the Israeli fence are both practical and political. Any wall can be breached, climbed over, undermined, tunneled under, or flown over. It will not deter enemies from firing rockets or mortars over the wall. In short, the wall may be ineffective in total deterrence of those determined to wage war on Israeli society.

Critics point to France`s Maginot Line as indicative of a failed strategy relying on a static defensive line for protection, but they draw the wrong historical lesson. The Maginot line was very effective in deterring a direct German attack on France`s eastern front, but the line was too short and left the northern Belgian border relatively undefended. That is where the Germans attacked, replaying their near-successful strategy of World War I.

For Israel, having a defensive wall or security fence to prevent easy entry for those intent on homicidal mischief is certainly better than having no barrier to such entry, despite its practical limitations in total defense. The key is to recognize the fence as just one tool in border control, and not to fall under the illusion that the wall will provide total protection.

The more significant arguments are political, chief among them that the security fence will demark the future boundaries of the planned Palestinian state, which should not be unilaterally decided by Israel.

Further, the Palestinian population is inconvenienced by the wall, which not only comes into what Palestinians believe is their territory, but also separates some areas of that territory from another.

Finally, the wall protects many Jewish settlements in what Palestinians desire as an ethnic-cleansed area, free of Jews.

At some point, political reality should intrude on these arguments. Israel fought five unsought wars to preserve its existence against the massed attacking armies of the surrounding Arab nations.
It magnanimously, if unwisely, acceded to Muslim control over the Temple Mount in Jerusalem after the 1967 war. Bending to humanitarian concerns, and counter to the lessons of all the wars of the 20th century, it did not expel the Arab population from Israel proper in the 1948 war nor the Arab population of Judah and Samaria (the West Bank) after capturing it from Jordan in the 1967 war. It did not engage in ethnic cleansing, though if it had, no doubt the present intractable population problems would not exist.

Israel has acceded to the view of a two-state solution, as it did in 1948 when the UN proposed it, even though wisdom would caution that a trusteeship or protectorate or mandate for the Palestinians would better fit the political realities than an irredentist nation, even one with limited sovereignty. It is not the right of the loser in war to dictate the terms of peace; neither the U.S. nor any other country has adopted such a standard for itself, though there is a concerted campaign to do just that with regard to Israel. The views of Israel as to its secure borders should be of greater import than the views of those who have been determined to destroy it. The wait for a peaceful, cooperative, accommodating, co-existing, non-irredentist Palestinian polity will be very long.

Inconvenience to Palestinians can be minimized by access gates in the fence, but again the political reality is that the security fence is necessary because Palestinians will not police themselves to prevent the attacks that the fence is designed to deter. Until Palestinians undertake the dismantlement of their militants, they will be inconvenienced, just as are the Israelis who are blown up in discos and pizza parlors.

As for the settlements, the current fashionable view is that Arabs have the right to live anywhere in the old Palestine Mandate ¡ª Israel, West Bank, Jordan ¡ª but Jews have only the disputed right to live in Israel proper. The West Bank area is to be ethnically cleansed of Jews, and their settlements used for Arab refugees. Logically, this should lead to another enforced population exchange, wherein the Arabs of Israel are relocated to the West Bank as the Jews there are expelled to Israel.

If ethnic cleansing is to be practiced, it should be equitably applied. Jews should be free to live in any part of the Mandate area; that they are not is a symptom of the problem`s intractable nature. Not long ago, a poll of Israeli Arabs ¡ª citizens of Israel ¡ª showed 38 percent opining that peaceful coexistence between Jews and Palestinians was not possible.

The corollary to the old proverb "fences make good neighbors" is that bad neighbors require good fences.?

Carl Pearlston, an attorney in the Los Angeles area, is an Annapolis graduate and former aerospace systems engineer.



Search article archive:

Israeli government surrenders to terrorism.. again By David Shalom with Betar UK - 16th Jul 08

What is a proportionate response? By Tom Carew - 5th Mar 08

Extortion Payout to Arab Mafia By Steven Shamrak - 6th Jan 08

On dialogue between Jews and Muslims By Isi Leibler - 1st Jan 08

Wake up call - Time to stop Annapolis Madness By David Shalom - 19th Nov 07

The Enemy Within By David Shalom - 8th Aug 07

Boycott Anglo Jewry By Jeremy Rosen - 22nd Jul 07

The Internal Fighting Between Hamas and Fatah in Gaza By Leon Ruskin - 27th Jun 07

A day in the life of Hebrew University By Angela Bertz - 6th Jun 07

In the Trenches: Why the British journalists union boycotts Israel By David Harris - 20th Apr 07

British journalists union boycott motion reflects deep animosity towards Israel By Chas Newkey Burden - 20th Apr 07

Weakness fosters anti-Semitism By ISI LEIBLER - 6th Nov 06

The media war against Israel By Melanie Philips - 5th Sep 06

The Civilian Casualties Are Aweful, But Israel Is Fighting For Its Existence By Richard Littlejohn - 4th Aug 06

Evidence mounts that Qana collapse and deaths were staged. By Reuven Koret - 31st Jul 06

Seeing Through The Fog Of War, The Truth... By Bernard J. Shapiro - 30th Jul 06

Why Israels Reaction to Hezbollah is Right By Matthias Küntzel - 28th Jul 06

Hezbollah, The war against Israel By Melanie Phillips - 27th Jul 06

Lunatic, Terrorist, Suicide Society By Amnon Dankner, Editor of Maariv Newspaper - 29th Jun 06

Those who celebrate death By Michael Freund - 16th May 06

Terror and Peace By Dori Gamliel - 1st Mar 06

Why the Hamas Victory is a Good Thing By Steven Plaut - 30th Jan 06

Two faces of an old bully By Shmuel Katz - 2nd Jan 06

Why Syria Welcomed David Duke By Dr. Rafael Medoff - 3rd Dec 05

The Right Strategy By Caroline Glick - 21st Oct 05

The Deliverance of Israel By Caleb Corbin - 15th Oct 05

Hold Palestinians accountable for Gaza synagogues destruction By Jerusalem Post - 14th Sep 05

Speech at Duke University by a Lebanese Christian By Brigitte Gabriel - 9th Sep 05

Was Arafat a Homosexual that died of Aids-UPDATED By Yaniv - 8th Sep 05

The End of Myhtology By Caroline Glick - 27th Aug 05

Is "Disengagement" promoting security, democracy and the economy? By Yoram Ettinger - 16th Aug 05

Ethnic Cleansing By Joseph Farah - 5th Aug 05

Does Corruption Drive Israeli Disengagement? By Rachel Neuwirth - 1st Aug 05

Where Now for the National Camp? By David Shalom - 20th Jul 05

The Beginning of the Reckoning By Caroline Glick - 17th Jul 05

'Orange fever' strikes Israel, Campaign colors country to stop Gaza evacuation By Aaron Klein - 13th Jul 05

The Israelification of Europe By Mark Steyn - 13th Jul 05

The BBC discovers ‘terrorism,’ briefly By Tom Gross - 12th Jul 05

The Lynch Against the Maoz Yam Hotel By Nadia Matar - 6th Jul 05

Disengaged from Reality By David Shalom - 6th Jul 05

Ariel Sharon - A coward for prime minister By Caroline Glick - 23rd Jun 05

A bolshevik state comes to Israel? By Israel Hanukoglu / Betar/ Women in Green - 19th May 05

This Year, Free Men? By Avi Hyman - 26th Apr 05

A dying lion that can still do harm/Britain's slide into self-destruction By Caroline Glick - 25th Apr 05

Pollard's freedom and our freedom By Caroline Glick - 24th Apr 05

BETAR joins fight for Gush Katif By Betar - 12th Apr 05

What Bush doesn't understand By Dr. Ron Breiman - 12th Apr 05

The Temple Mount Secret By Boris Shusteff - 11th Apr 05

Betar fights PLO on Oxford street By Betar-Tagar UK - 3rd Apr 05

Our World: The Holocaust Fetish By Caroline Glick - 2nd Apr 05


All Graphics Text, Control Management System Copyright Betar Tagar UK 2002 - Website Designers